Is organic meat better? Is meat from humane farming better?
Created on: March 20, 2026
Last edited on: March 20, 2026
Many people want to consume meat more consciously and therefore choose products from higher welfare tiers or with labels such as organic. But what exactly lies behind these terms? We provide clarity about the reality for the animals.
Disclaimer 1: Since we place great importance on fact-based, objective education, the farming methods are not ethically evaluated from the outset. However, we recommend trying to put yourself in the animals’ situation. Think of crowded house parties or subways. You decide how much time you spend there - the animals do not have that choice.
Disclaimer 2: The regulations described here refer to Germany and the EU. Similar basic principles - such as more space, access to outdoor areas, or stricter requirements for organic farming - can also be found in other countries like the UK, Canada, or Australia. However, the specific rules, controls, and labeling systems sometimes differ significantly. In the United States, the legal minimum standards are less strict in many areas, although additional voluntary animal welfare programs may also exist there. The ethical evaluation at the end applies worldwide and is independent of the specific type of animal farming.
What do farming systems 1 to 5 mean?
On many meat products in german supermarkets, you can find the retailer-specific labeling system with farming levels 1 to 5. We break down what these levels mean for the animals.
Farming system 1 - Indoor farming
This level essentially corresponds to the legal minimum requirements in Germany. In practice, this means a life indoors without mandatory access to outdoor areas.
Concrete examples for illustration: Fattening pigs weighing up to 110 kg have about 0.75 square meters of space per animal. For broiler chickens, the legal minimum standard is 39 kg of live weight per square meter of barn space. This roughly corresponds (depending on the exact weight) to 19-20 chickens per m². This means each chicken has less space than a sheet of A4 paper.
Farming system 2 - Indoor farming + space
Here, animals are given slightly more space in the barn and straw bedding. Access to outdoor areas is still not required. Examples:
- Pigs (fattening pigs up to 110 kg): approx. 0.84 m² per animal
- Broiler chickens: max. 35 kg live weight per m² → roughly equivalent to 17-18 chickens per m²
Farming system 3 - Fresh air barn
At this level, animals must at least have contact with outside air. This can be achieved, for example, through open sides of the barn. The space per animal is also increased. Examples:
- Pigs (fattening pigs ~110 kg): approx. 1.3 m² per animal (in open-front housing)
- Broiler chickens: depending on the program, max. 30 kg live weight per m² → roughly equivalent to 14-16 chickens per m²
Example image of a fresh air barn
Farming system 4 - Outdoor access / pasture
This level represents the highest category of conventional farming systems. Access to outdoor areas is mandatory. Examples:
- Pigs (fattening pigs ~110 kg): approx. 1.5 m² per animal, OF WHICH at least 0.5 m² outdoor area per animal
- Broiler chickens: max. 25 kg live weight per m² → roughly equivalent to 12-13 chickens per m²; additionally about 2 m² outdoor area per animal
Farming system 5 - Organic
This level was added in 2024 and corresponds to the requirements of organic farming. Animals are given more space, mandatory outdoor access, and additional requirements, including feed standards. Examples:
- Pigs (fattening pigs up to 110 kg): approx. 1.3 m² per animal; additionally at least 1 m² outdoor area per animal
- Broiler chickens: max. 21 kg live weight per m² → roughly equivalent to 10-11 chickens per m² - meaning each chicken has approximately the space of 1.5 A4 sheets -; additionally at least 4 m² outdoor area per animal
What does organic mean?
Here, the specific label makes a difference. We examine the EU regulation as well as organic certifications whose standards go beyond it.
EU organic
Most organic meat comes from farms that follow the requirements of the EU Organic Regulation. These standards are stricter than those of conventional animal farming - animals must have more space in the barn and access to outdoor areas. In addition, the total number of animals per barn is more strictly limited, and feed from organic farming (regarding pesticides, fertilizers, and genetic engineering) must be used. Certain medications and growth promoters are also more restricted.
How much space do animals have in organic farming? A fattening pig weighing up to 110 kg has - as described above under farming system 5 - 1.3 m² of space in the barn and 1 m² outdoors. For broiler chickens, a maximum of 21 kg live weight per m² applies in the barn and 4 m² in outdoor areas. There are no specific time requirements for how long animals must stay outside. Formally, a farm could therefore allow animals outside only for a very short time and still meet the basic requirement, as long as access is provided.
Organic meat vs factory farming
Factory farming is not a clearly defined legal term, but essentially describes a highly standardized system focused on efficiency, with many animals kept in limited space. Organic farming is also based on these principles - albeit under stricter legal minimum requirements. For example, under the EU Organic Regulation, barn units with up to 4,800 broiler chickens are permitted.
Are organic animals slaughtered differently?
In practice, the slaughter process is largely identical. Slaughter facilities and processes are often the same or very similar. The main difference usually lies not in the procedure itself, but in the organization: animals from organic farming are often slaughtered separately in time. This separation primarily serves labeling and traceability purposes, not a fundamentally different slaughter method.
Strictest German organic label
To obtain a Demeter organic label, fattening pigs up to around 110 kg must also have at least 1.3 m² of barn space and about 1 m² of outdoor area per animal.
For broiler chickens, Demeter allows a maximum of around 16 kg live weight per m² in the barn, as well as roughly 4 m² of outdoor space per animal. This shows that the mandatory indoor space here is greater than in any other farming system. However, there are still about 6 to 8 chickens per square meter - roughly the size of a shower cubicle.
Even under the Demeter label, there are no specific hourly requirements, but regular outdoor access is expected. For example, cattle are subject to a clear grazing requirement during the grazing season - however, although tethering is no longer allowed in new farms, it is still permitted in existing small farms. In some cases, it has been documented that cattle are kept tethered continuously for extended periods during winter. Farms are usually inspected once a year, with most inspections being announced in advance.
Even for those who only buy fruit or vegetables: Germany’s highest organic label requires the use of animal manure as fertilizer - meaning animal farming is structurally embedded, not optional. Anyone buying Demeter products is financially supporting this system.
What does species-appropriate farming mean? What does animal welfare mean?
The Farm Animal Welfare Council defines five freedoms that are intended to guide animal welfare and species-appropriate farming:
- Freedom from hunger and thirst
- Freedom from discomfort
- Freedom from pain, injury or disease
- Freedom to express normal behavior
- Freedom from fear and distress
To what extent these criteria are actually met in the farming systems described is something each individual can assess for themselves.
It is important to understand that there is no legally defined definition of “species-appropriate” or “animal welfare.” The term is not protected and can therefore be used very differently by producers. In practice, it is often simply a marketing term.
The vegan perspective - farming systems and ethics
There are undoubtedly clear differences between the farming systems. At the same time, for a fair evaluation, we should ask ourselves whether we would want to live in any of these systems.
Let’s use the conditions of the highest german organic label as an example: a fattening pig (approx. 110 kg) is allocated 1.3 m² of indoor space and 1 m² of outdoor space. As a thought experiment, imagine having to spend your life in a slightly larger shower cubicle and being allowed to take one or two steps outside. Would you be satisfied? Or would it feel restrictive? And why do we still tell ourselves that “they are just animals,” while we often feel sorry for indoor cats due to lack of space? These questions are uncomfortable, but they matter.
What has not yet been mentioned is the end of life in the slaughterhouse, which all animals bred for meat and who survive their farming conditions ultimately share. At the latest at this point, most of us are probably relieved to have been born into the human species by chance.
By the way, animals also end up in slaughterhouses because of dairy products and eggs.
Summary
In Germany, there are several systems that label animal farming conditions. Levels 1 and 2 are the most common, while the higher levels 3 and 4 are significantly less frequent. According to the independent German consumer organization Stiftung Warentest (2025), 83% of meat comes from the two lowest levels and 93% from levels 1 to 3. This means that around 93% of animals raised for meat likely spend their lives in barns without access to the outdoors.
In addition, other animal products such as milk, cheese, eggs, or wool are usually not labeled at all. Regardless of the specific farming system or animal welfare label, animals within these systems are considered commodities. The systems are designed to keep many animals efficiently and profitably. It is reasonable to speculate that existing labels are intended more to give consumers a good feeling than to genuinely address the interests of the animals.
At the latest, when animals are murdered for meat, their interest in continuing to live is clearly overridden. Therefore, we do not advocate for improved farming conditions, but for the abolition of the slave status of sentient beings and for the introduction of animal rights.
➡️ Share our answer:
